why was the amendment process included in the constitution
Some constitutional scholars believe that Article V, which sets forth the amendment process, is the key to the Constitution's success. It establishes a process where adding amendments is not too easy, which would make the Constitution more like statutory law and less permanentБbut also not too diffi-cult, which would make violent revolution more likely. A proposed amendment must pass a two-thirds vote in both houses of Congress, or if two-thirds of the states petition Congress, a new constitutional convention can be called to consider amendments. In any event, three-fourths of the state legislatures must ratify the amendment for it to become a permanent part of the Constitution. Calling for a convention to amend the Constitution might actually be the best way to create a new one. After all, the Philadelphia convention in 1787 was supposed to amend the Articles of Confederation, the existing constitution. Instead, the delegates proposed an entirely different system of government. It took effect after state conventions especially elected for the purpose chose to ratify the new Constitution.
According to Yale Law Professor Akhil Reed Amar, Бthe ratification of the Constitution was. the most participatory, majoritarian, and populist event the Earth had ever seen. Б But 225 years later, some Americans want to begin anew. We the People content written by Linda R. Monk, Constitutional scholar
The Speaker of the House of Representatives, Yakubu Dogara, yesterday confirmed that the processes of effecting new amendments to the 1999 Constitution was put on Бhold because the Senate and the House had not harmonised their differences on the bills. The two chambers considered 33 proposals in July, but the outcome of voting indicated that they did not agree on all the items. The differences will require a conference committee of both chambers to harmonise them before the amendments will be transmitted to the 36 state Houses of Assembly for Бapproval. Б Dogara spoke at the National Assembly in Abuja when a delegation of the Conference of Speakers of Nigerian State Legislatures visited him. The speakers were led by their Chairman, Ismaila Abdulmumin-Kamba.
Under the 1999 Constitution, a proposal to amend the constitution must secure two-thirds majority vote of both chambers of the National Assembly to pass. It must in turn secure the БapprovalБ of two-thirds majority (24) of the 36 statesБ Houses of Assembly to be included in the constitution. A statement by the SpeakerБs Media Office on Wednesday said Dogara admitted that the new constitution could not leave the National Assembly because it had yet to be harmonised in Abuja. БHe also explained the delay in the transmission of the Constitution Amendment Bills recently passed by both chambers of the National Assembly to state MPs, saying it is as a result of ongoing consultations between the two houses to harmonise all areas of differences in order to produce a uniform documentБ, the statement said. At the meeting, Dogara also complained of biting poverty in the country, saying that the legislature at all levels must join in the search for workable solutions. БWe know that if something has to be done at the level of government that will translate into a better life for our people, it must begin from the local government level, at the state level, and then before we even talk about the federal level,Б he added.
The Speaker advised state lawmakers to be firm in dealing with the executive rather than giving in to all of their demands. БIn democracy, we worship no one, we should fear only God but we respect men. БWhen you have a parliament that only responds to the demands of the executive, there is no way we can make progress. We have to carry out our responsibilities without having any fear at all,Б he said. The speakers had earlier assured Dogara that they would act on the constitution bills as soon as they were transmitted to the states. Their chairman added, БWe, at the Conference of Speakers, are ready to do justice to these issues. We have already concluded that whatever you will transmit to us, we will carry our strata and groups along and agree that whatever the majority may agree on will be carried out. Б
- Views: 44
why do we have amendments to the constitution
why do we have amendments in our constitution
why do we have a bicameral congress
why do we have the constitution of the united states
why do we have the bill of rights
why was the ratification of the constitution important
why were the first ten amendments added to the constitution